Exploring The Most Haunted Places In Indiana: A Guide To Local Spooks & Spirits

By Bob •  Updated: 01/03/23 •  10 min read

Are you looking for a spine-tingling adventure?

If so, then Indiana is the perfect place to explore some of the most haunted locations in the United States.

From abandoned mental asylums to ancient battlefields, this guide will take you on an exciting journey into the unknown and expose you to some of Indiana’s oldest spooks and spirits.

So get ready to be scared–it’s time to dive deep into Indiana’s darkest secrets!

Haunted Places in Indiana

1. Old State Prison, Michigan City

The Old State Prison in Michigan City, Indiana has a long and dark history.

Built in 1859 to house inmates convicted of various crimes, this prison was home to some notorious criminals over the years.

It closed its doors for the last time in 1965 and now sits abandoned on the east side of Michigan City’s coast.

Many people believe that due to its dark past, the Old State Prison is haunted by spirits from beyond. Reports include strange noises coming from within the walls, as well as figures seen walking around inside at night. There have also been sightings of ghostly faces peering out from windows and doorways throughout the building.

If you’re feeling brave enough to explore this spooky site yourself, there are guided tours available! You can contact their website (www.michigancityprisonhistorytours) for more information about dates and times or email them directly at michigancityprisontours@gmail.com

2. Willard Library Ghost, Evansville

Willard Library in Evansville, Indiana is an historic library with a long history of paranormal activity. The library was founded in 1885 by Reverend Willard Carpenter and his wife, Sarah. It has been said that the pair still haunt the building to this day.

The most famous ghost story associated with Willard Library is that of “The Grey Lady” who reportedly haunts the upper floors of the library. According to legend, she wears a grey dress and veil and carries a single white rose as she wanders through the stacks. Witnesses have reported seeing her disappear into walls or vanish suddenly right before their eyes!

Other paranormal activity at Willard Library includes mysterious noises such as whispers, footsteps, doors slamming shut without cause; sightings of other apparitions like Sarah Carpenter walking up and down stairs carrying books; items moving on their own or being misplaced; lights flickering on and off; unusual cold spots throughout the building even during warm weather months; objects going missing for no apparent reason only to reappear days later in strange places within the library—and more!

If you’d like to learn more about this haunted location please visit: http://willardlibraryghostsproject.com/.

3. Stiffy Green the Mule, Greensburg

Located in Greensburg, Kentucky, Stiffy Green the Mule is said to be one of the most haunted locations in the state. The legend surrounding this location dates back to 1813 when a farmer named John Fox was on his way to town with his mule, Stiffy Green. As they passed through an old graveyard near what is now downtown Greensburg, lightning struck and killed both of them instantly.

Since then, people have reported seeing strange lights coming from the area where Stiffy Green and John Fox were killed. Some people claim they’ve even seen a ghostly figure riding a white mule galloping across fields at night! Others say that if you listen closely enough you can hear whinnying coming from somewhere deep in the woods near where Stiffy Green died.

To this day local residents still tell stories about this mysterious place and its eerie history. If you’re feeling brave enough for an adventure there’s no better place than Stiffy Green’s hauntings! For more information about tours or other events related to Stiffy Green’s story visit www.stiffygreensmulehauntingsky .com

4. The Lady in White of the Madison-Vernon Cemetery, Madison

The Madison-Vernon Cemetery, located in the small city of Madison, Indiana, is said to be haunted by a female spirit known as the Lady in White. According to local legend, a woman was buried alive at this cemetery during the early 20th century due to an accidental misdiagnosis of death. Her ghost is said to roam the grounds and haunt visitors who visit her grave.

Several reports have been made over the years of people seeing or hearing strange noises coming from around her grave site late at night. Some even claim they’ve seen a white figure walking through the cemetery and disappearing into thin air when approached. Visitors also report feelings of dread and unease while walking through certain parts of the graveyard, especially those near her resting place.

Those brave enough to visit can find her location with relative ease using online resources such as Find A Grave (www.findagrave.com). While there has yet to be any formal research conducted on this particular haunting tale, it remains one that continues captivate locals for many generations in Madison County and beyond!

5. The Hanging Tree at Fort Wayne Children’s Zoo

The Fort Wayne Children’s Zoo in Indiana is a popular destination for families, but it also has a darker history that many locals know about. The zoo is said to be haunted by the ghost of an unnamed woman who was hung from the Hanging Tree at the entrance of the park.

Legend has it that during the Civil War, a woman named Sarah was accused of being a Confederate spy and sentenced to death by hanging. She was taken to what is now known as Fort Wayne Children’s Zoo and hanged from an old oak tree near its entrance. To this day, people claim to have seen her spirit dancing around in white robes near where she died on nights when there is no moonlight visible. Others say they hear faint singing coming from deep within the forest surrounding the zoo late at night.

If you are interested in learning more about this haunting legend or visiting Fort Wayne Children’s Zoo, please visit their website: https://kidszoo.org/.

6. Haunted Train Tracks near Terre Haute

The Haunted Train Tracks near Terre Haute, Indiana have become a popular destination for thrill seekers looking to experience some paranormal activity. The legend is that a railroad worker was killed in an accident on the tracks and his ghost still lingers there today. People who have visited the location report hearing strange noises along with feeling cold spots and unexplained sensations of being watched. Some visitors even claim to have seen the ghost of the railroad worker walking across the tracks!

If you’re looking for an exciting adventure, exploring these train tracks may be just what you need! Be sure to bring your flashlight as it can get quite dark at night and always use caution when traveling around abandoned railways. For more information about this haunted location, check out their website: https://www.hauntedamericatours.com/terrehautetraintracks/.

7. Waverly Hills Sanatorium, Louisville

The Waverly Hills Sanatorium in Louisville, Kentucky is one of the most haunted places in America. It was originally built to help contain and treat tuberculosis patients during the early 1900s, but it soon became a place of death for thousands as the disease would claim lives quickly. The building has been described by many as being filled with dark energy and oppressive feelings due to its tragic past. People have reported hearing footsteps and strange noises coming from within the walls, feeling cold spots throughout the halls and seeing apparitions moving around inside or looking out windows.

Some say that two of the most commonly seen ghosts are Mary Hillenburg who died at age 20 in Room 502 after suffering from tuberculosis; her ghost is said to wander along corridors on certain nights searching for her lost love William Thomas who also died at Waverly Hills. Another famous ghost is known as ‘Timmy’ – he was an 8-year-old boy who committed suicide by jumping off a balcony while visiting his sick mother at Waverly Hills – people often report seeing him running through some parts of the hallways and playing with visitors children before suddenly disappearing into thin air!

Today, visitors can take guided tours of this historic location or even stay overnight if they dare! Tours start from $50 per person (plus tax). For more information visit www.therealwaverlyhills.com

8. Rose Island Amusement Park Ruins, Charlestown

The ruins of Rose Island Amusement Park are located in Charlestown, Rhode Island. The park was originally opened in the late 19th century and operated until its closure in 1971. It was a popular attraction for residents and visitors alike, but has since been abandoned and left to decay.

In recent years, there have been numerous reports of strange phenomena occurring at the site. Many visitors claim to have heard disembodied voices or felt an eerie presence while walking the grounds. Others report seeing odd lights flickering through the windows of some of the structures that remain standing onsite. Some believe these sightings could be evidence of paranormal activity at this former amusement park location.

Given its reputation as a haunted location, Rose Island Amusement Park Ruins has become a popular destination for ghost hunters looking to investigate potential paranormal activity first-hand. If you’re interested in visiting yourself, please note that access is restricted due to safety concerns so it’s best to plan your visit with caution before attempting any exploration here! For more information about Rose Island Amusement Park Ruins, please check out their official website: https://www.roseislandparkruinsri.com/

9. Chinese Dragon of Speedway High School Theater Stage, Speedway

The Speedway High School Theater Stage, located in Speedway, Indiana is said to be haunted by a mysterious Chinese dragon. According to local legend, the ghostly creature appears as a large red dragon with glowing eyes and is heard hissing and growling throughout the theater.

It’s believed that this spectral presence was once part of an old performance that took place at the theater many years ago. The story goes that during one of these performances, actors were acting out a scene involving dragons when suddenly one of them went missing from the stage! It’s theorized that this actor may have become trapped inside their costume and died there on stage before anyone could help him.

Since then, some people have reported hearing strange noises coming from backstage or seeing glimpses of something moving around in the darkness. Others claim to feel a cold chill run through their body whenever they enter or exit the theater auditorium. Some even say they can sense an eerie presence watching them while they’re performing onstage!

Although no one has been able to confirm if this supernatural entity really exists or not, it certainly adds an extra element of intrigue for visitors visiting Speedway High School Theater Stage! For more information about Speedway High School Theatre Stage you can visit speedwayhighschooltheatrestage/com/.

10. Grey Lady of University Hall at Indiana University Bloomington

The Grey Lady of University Hall at Indiana University Bloomington has been a source of mystery and intrigue since the building’s construction in 1868. According to legend, she is the ghost of Sarah Morris, who died tragically before the building was completed. Her story goes that she fell in love with a man who rejected her advances and then committed suicide by jumping off the top floor balcony. Since then, it is said that her spirit haunts University Hall, appearing as an apparition dressed all in grey on certain occasions. Some students have even reported feeling a presence when inside or outside of the building late at night.

For more information about this eerie location and its haunted history, you can visit Indiana University’s website for official records regarding paranormal activity: https://www.indiana.edu/~univhall/.